Quick Hits
Daily brief research updates from the cognitive sciences
Voting is something many of us do regularly as adults in different ways. But the most common way is plurality voting – that is one voter for one person that can only be cast once.
However, there are different ways to vote. Popular shows such as American Idol use multivoting whereby the audience memebrs have 10 votes to share as they see fit. They can use all ten for one candidate or distribute them as they wish across candidates.
Another method is ranked-choice whereby choices should be ranked in the order one sees as best.
The question though is what is best? This is the question researchers at the University of Washington wanted to find out but specifically into what enables better decision making. In many decision-making bodies such as in business or government simple plurality voting is used.
To do this the researchers used 93 teams of graduates in an anti-terrorism exercise modelled on teams used post 9/11. 31 teams each used the different voting methods. They first read information on three suspects and voted on who they thought was the greatest threat – they then discussed the suspects after the vote, and then voted again.
In the plurality voting scenario, teams identified the correct suspect only 31% of the time. Basically, around about pure chance. So actually ineffective. Did the other voting scenarios perform better?
Well, ranked-choice performed only a little better with 32% of the time. But the largest difference was in multivoting – here 45% of teams identified the correct suspect. But there was another surprise.
This was that multivoting seemed to be more effective before the discussion. We would assume that voting and then discussing would lead to better insight and therefore making a better decision. But this was not the case. In multivoting it seems that it forces people to think through things more carefully in the first place. The ensuing discussion can then side-track thinking for multiple reasons.
So, according to this research at least, multivoting is easily the most effective method for making decisions. Something many businesses should seriously consider – particularly in important decisions – and prior to discussion!
It could be too complicated for political voting but then again, I live in Switzerland, and we already use a similar version. Implementing this in a different country would be a challenge – but for now, for decision-making, we do know that multivoting appears to be the best method. Well, for what it’s worth, it has my vote(s).

Andy Habermacher
Andy is author of leading brains Review, Neuroleadership, and multiple other books. He has been intensively involved in writing and research into neuroleadership and is considered one of Europe’s leading experts. He is also a well-known public speaker, speaking on the brain and human behaviour.
Andy is also a masters athlete (middle distance running) and competes regularly at international competitions (and holds a few national records in his age category).
References
Michael D Johnson, Eli Awtrey, Wei Jee Ong.
Verdicts, Elections, and Counterterrorism: When Groups Take Unofficial Votes.
Academy of Management Discoveries, 2022
DOI: 10.5465/amd.2021.0099
More Quick Hits
Brain Scans Can Predict Your Political Affiliation
Quick HitsDaily brief research updates from the cognitive sciences rain scanning of political partisans is not new and it has long been reported that brain scans can predict political affiliation. But those studies were scans of political partisans...
Children with Same-Sex Parents Are Socially Well-Adjusted
Quick HitDaily brief research updates from the cognitive sciences his is not the first study to report that children of same-sex parents are well adjusted, there are plenty, but it is one of the first to be representative and hence gives some...
Simple Exposure to New Things Makes Your Brain Ready to Learn
ouldn’t it be great if we could learn things with no effort? Well, actually we often do, and children learn vast quantities of information, and knowledge with little to no effort – think of how well we learn languages which become fiendishly...
So, Can Cranberries Improve Memory?
tend to be hesitant to report on studies of single foods doing amazing things (because many do), but this piece of research still caught my eye. So, what did this group of researchers from the University of East Anglia find? Well, they...
The Real Problem with Social Media: It Induces Dissociative States
Quick HitsDaily brief research updates from the cognitive sciences ocial media seems to hijack our brains – or at least according to popular narratives. Most of us have experienced this where you get stuck in an endless stream of content,...
Adventurous Play Boosts Mental Resilience in Kids
o, a simple cheap way to help your kids improve all life skills and strengthen mental wellbeing. Too good to be true? Well, this piece of research, just out, finds a fascinating correlation with mental health and kids. This correlation was...