Quick Hits
Daily brief research updates from the cognitive sciences
Recently I reported on one conundrum of learning in groups: that of optimal group formation i.e. should you group learners with similar ability or diverging ability for the best average learning outcomes.
That question seems to have been resolved. However, there remain other questions such as how does group interaction affect learning?
A recently published study by Stephanie Halmo et al. of the University of Georgia has given us some interesting new insights into this.
To do this the researchers recorded the conversation of students in breakout groups in collaborative learning tasks. They analysed the conversation and identified a number of meta-cognitive statements that helped to move learning forward these included asking for clarification, checking that the discussions and reasoning was guiding towards the actual goals of the group, but also, importantly, of correcting other students.
This correcting of other students seems to be particularly important – not just for the person being corrected but the whole groups. It is likely also the most difficult to do because of politeness or fear of conflict – yet this shows this is precisely the most important thing to do and serves the collective.
Another interesting feature and one that is counter intuitive is that long periods of silence were also indicative of better learning – in this group work we may often think of talkative groups as being the most effective but the data showed otherwise.
There could be multiple reasons for this: lack of attention, lack of deep thought, a constant barrage of chatter, etc. It goes against our intuitions because if we see groups chatting a lot, we perceive high collaboration and therefore assume effective learning. This applies to the group itself as well as the educator guiding this learning.
So, all in when learning in groups, do interact, but be thoughtful, guide towards the goal, and do correct others when suitable. That will make group learning more effective. And I’ve certainly just learned something.

Andy Habermacher
Andy is author of leading brains Review, Neuroleadership, and multiple other books. He has been intensively involved in writing and research into neuroleadership and is considered one of Europe’s leading experts. He is also a well-known public speaker, speaking on the brain and human behaviour.
Andy is also a masters athlete (middle distance running) and competes regularly at international competitions (and holds a few national records in his age category).
References
Stephanie M. Halmo, Emily K. Bremers, Sammantha Fuller, Julie Dangremond Stanton.
“Oh, that makes sense”: Social Metacognition in Small-Group Problem Solving.
CBE—Life Sciences Education, 2022; 21 (3)
DOI: 10.1187/cbe.22-01-0009
More Quick Hits
How Meditation Helps Pain In Your Brain
Quick HitsDaily brief research updates from the cognitive sciences es, meditation can help with pain by changing your experience of it. I reported on that here. Another piece of research just published shows that how experienced meditators and...
When Stress Is Good For Brain Functioning
Quick HitsDaily brief research updates from the cognitive sciences tress gets a bad rap – understandably it is a negative experience and has been shown over long periods of time, and with high intensity, to cause multiple negative outcomes, from...
Put Your Smartphone Down and Let your Mind Wander – You’ll Be Happier
Quick HitsDaily brief research updates from the cognitive sciences here’s a lot been said about smartphone usage and how it can be used and abused. Most of this concern revolves around usage in children or teenagers, however, with some research...
The Amazing Impact Of Reaching Out To Your Old Friends
Quick HitsDaily brief research updates from the cognitive sciences few weeks ago a friend I hadn’t seen for about 10 years sent me a message and asked if I had time to meet up. I was elated. "Sure," I immediately messaged back, "when and where?!"...
Really? Belief In Conspiracies Not Increasing
Quick HitsDaily brief research updates from the cognitive sciences e may feel like we’re in an age of conspiracy theories, that social media is turbocharging the wild and wacky theories, and the so-called information bubbles are sending people down...
You Wake Up 100 Times Each Night – And That Helps Memory
Quick HitsDaily brief research updates from the cognitive sciences have written numerous posts and articles on sleep and the brain (review here), and the evidence is crystal clear. Good and consistent sleep is essential to all aspects of physical...