Quick Hits
Daily brief research updates from the cognitive sciences
Us vs. them is known as in-groups vs. out-groups in psychology. This is the well-known effect of people being loyal to their own groups and being competitive and often aggressive to the out-group. This happens in multiple groups. Obvious ones are nationalities, religious groups, sports teams, but also geographical regions.
Previous research has shown that we human beings are very good at creating groups and this can be formed very quickly. We also know that these groups, at extreme levels, can be the cause of much of what we consider evil in society, aggression, abuse, murder, torture, and genocide. What may also be surprising, to some, is that all evidence points to this being hardwired i.e. babies as young as 3-months-old exhibit favouritism to in-groups and out-groups and this includes punishing the out-group and rewarding the in-group!
Now researchers at the Virginia Commonwealth University have investigated this effect further and come to some surprising, to some, conclusions!
What did they find?
They put 35 male college students through online competitive aggressive tasks. For this they told they would be competing with participants from a rival university. In fact, they competed against a computer – for ethical reasons. They had their brains scanned while doing these tasks.
What they found that was surprising is that those who were more aggressive against out-group members had greater activation of reward circuits in the brain suggesting that this is driven be reward rather than anger or other mechanisms. Specifically, the nucleus accumbens and ventromedial prefrontal cortex.
This reward circuitry was also associated with the mount they excluded the out-group from other activities. Though this has been measured in other contexts and the research points to this rewarding experience the researchers were most surprised by the strength of the effect in what is a “weak” out-group. A rival university is, in the big scale of things, not a very strong out-group such as the ones that are constructed in a divisive political atmosphere or on the global stage.
So sad to say that reward for punishing others seems to drive, to a large extent, in- and out-grouping and harming others. Fortunately, we now know this and fortunately not everybody exhibits this to excessive degrees●

Andy Habermacher
Andy is author of leading brains Review, Neuroleadership, and multiple other books. He has been intensively involved in writing and research into neuroleadership and is considered one of Europe’s leading experts. He is also a well-known public speaker speaking on the brain and human behaviour.
Andy is also a masters athlete (middle distance running) and competes regularly at international competitions (and holds a few national records in his age category).
Reference
Emily Lasko, Abigale C Dagher, Samuel James West, David Chester.
Neural Mechanisms of Intergroup Exclusion and Retaliatory Aggression.
Social Neuroscience, 2022
More Quick Hits
You Wake Up 100 Times Each Night – And That Helps Memory
Quick HitsDaily brief research updates from the cognitive sciences have written numerous posts and articles on sleep and the brain (review here), and the evidence is crystal clear. Good and consistent sleep is essential to all aspects of physical...
Only Three Factors Can Predict Mental Illness With 90% Accuracy
Quick HitsDaily brief research updates from the cognitive sciences here are multiple mental disorders that can afflict us human beings. And the assumption is that these are complex in nature and there are a multitude of paths to mental illness....
Cooperation Amongst Strangers Is On the Rise
Quick HitsDaily brief research updates from the cognitive sciences espite a belief in many that society is falling apart and becoming less caring and social this study proves the opposite. A study published by Yuan et al. with the American...
Brain Network For Social Attraction Identified
Quick HitsDaily brief research updates from the cognitive sciences umans do it. Birds do it. Fish do it. So do multitudes of other species. We flock together, come together, are attracted to our kind. We are a social species. But the question is...
The Brainwaves That Boost Creativity
Quick HitsDaily brief research updates from the cognitive sciences outlined here how recent research has shown that the brains of highly creative individuals use different networks, and this also reminded me of separate piece of research from a...
How Creative Brains Function Differently
Quick HitsDaily brief research updates from the cognitive sciences an you learn creativity? Well, you can learn anything, and you can certainly learn to be more creative. But the big question is do those people high in creativity have brains that...